Florida Eats: Kappy’s Subs

Part of the fun of exploring Florida is finding interesting places to dine or visit.  Sometimes you find them just by driving the back roads.  Other times they appear in unlikely places.  Who would have thought one of those locations sits in the shadows of new development in Maitland?

Kappy’s History

Kappy’s Subs has been a Maitland icon for more than 50 years, serving Central Florida customers since 1967.  This unpretentious diner backs up to the railroad tracks and sits at the busy intersection of Sybelia and 17-92.  New construction flanks two of the corners, a 7-11 sits on the third. The environment around this diner have changed, but the owners (it has been in the same family since 1972) haven’t changed a thing.

The Ambiance

Part of the allure of Kappy’s is its ambiance. Don’t go if you’re expecting a fine dining experience.  This is fifties dining at its finest – inside or out. Place your order at the walk-up window, then sit in your car in the limited covered parking outside or have a seat at one of the picnic tables for that true outdoor Florida feel.

Inside, an L-shaped counter lined with 12 swiveling stainless bar stools with burgundy vinyl seats welcome a limited number of guests.  The sound of grease bubbling in the deep fryer indicates a fresh batch of onion rings is being cooked. A waitress yells out “burger” to the cook.  No matter where you sit at the counter, you can view of the grill as your food selection is cooked.

On the Menu

The menu offers up typical diner food – everything from burgers to chicken nuggets to sandwiches, hot dogs and subs.

For me, the Philly Cheesesteak piqued my culinary curiosity (on both recent visits).  It’s one of Kappy’s specialties and it didn’t disappoint.  In all honesty, I didn’t experience the true cheesesteak.  I’m not much on peppers, so I went with the cheese and onions and added on mushrooms.  My dining companion tried the Fatima’s Sensation, with roast beef, grilled onions and mushrooms, plus melted Swiss cheese and a tangy BBQ sauce. On another occasion, he tried The Rodney, with pastrami, onions, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.  Coupled with onion rings, our lunches were, as the sign outside says, “yummy.”

We both topped off our meals with a chocolate milk shake, made fresh in front of us.  It was creamy, and it was delicious.

Kappy’s Hours

If you’re looking for a change from fast food restaurants and want something more authentic, Kappy’s is the place to go. It is open Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. until 9:00 p.m., on Saturday from 10:30 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., and on Sunday from 11:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.

If you visit, let us know what you think.

Floridiana Magazine (FM) Note: After publication we received additional information from the family about Kappy’s.  It operated as a Valentine Diner in 1964. (In case you’re interested, a Valentine Diner was a small diner that seated eight to twelve people with a limited menu, making it possible for one or two people to run with limited capital.) The establishment also operated as a What-A-Burger for two years and, after closing, reopened as Kappy’s by Isadore Kaplan around 1967 . Bob Caplan (with a “C”) purchased Kappy’s in 1972 and the diner has been in the family ever since.